9 Activities to Teach Citation and Documentation

Simple Flowchart: When do you cite? Did you think of it? Yes. Do not cite it. Did you think of it? No. Is it common knowledge? Yes. Do not cite it. Did you think of it? No. Is it common knowledge? No. Cite it.

 

"Teaching Citation and Documentation Norms" (post; pdf) presents an overview, general considerations, and nine specific, in-class activities which are useful "when teaching students the citation norms in your discipline."

"[A]ctivities can be designed to discourage plagiarism and to help students identify the rhetorical value of citations."

  • "[A]ddress the issues of avoiding plagiarism and producing proper formatting first, in order to relieve student anxieties about these questions."
  • "[T]hen move on to helping students see how they can use citation norms to position themselves within a larger scholarly discourse."

A. Overview: Two Approaches

1. "[F]ocus primarily on avoiding plagiarism and producing appropriately formatted in-text citations and reference lists."

  • "[P]referable if you have limited time available."

2. "[U]se a discussion of citation norms as an opportunity to help students become more aware of how those norms function rhetorically within your scholarly community."

  • "[A]llow[s] for deeper understanding of how to interpret and produce key scholarly moves."

B. General Considerations

1. What "undergraduates at all levels don’t necessarily understand"

  • "How to integrate in-text citations properly"
  • "How to format reference lists and understand the logic behind the formatting rules"
  • "How to determine what kind of sources they are working with ... and where to locate key identifying information to cite"
  • "That ... the cobbling together of snippets gathered from many sources is plagiarism"
  • "What counts as common knowledge in your discipline and what needs to be cited"

2. "[O]ther crucial tasks that students might not immediately recognize"

  • "Providing research aid to those studying similar questions"
  • "Establishing credibility—showing that one has read and understood key works"
  • "Drawing attention to the contributions of others"
  • "Signaling original contributions—citing work by others in order to highlight what is new in one’s own"

C. Teaching Activities

1. Walk students through a published journal article in your field.

  • "Ask them to describe the in-text citations they see."
  • "When—if ever—are authors’ names introduced within sentences ('According to Brown and White…')?"
  • "[W]hen are they tucked into parentheses '(Brown and White, 1999)'?"
  • "Help them interpret the significance of these differences."

2. "Ask students to describe and interpret the patterns they see in a reference list or bibliography." 

  • "What characteristics appear first? What appears second?"
  • "Why might these things appear in the order they do?"

3. "Give students a selection of sources to cite, along with a citation guide."

  • "Ask them to produce, individually or in groups, a properly formatted reference list."
  • "Make sure some of sources are unusual—compact discs, comic strips, data from a government web site—and that others lack explicit labels for key identifiers such as volume or issue number."
  • "Help students figure out how to cite these works as questions arise."

4. "Have students read a paragraph built from patchwork plagiarism and then another version of that paragraph that has been properly paraphrased and cited." 

  • "Ask the students, individually or in groups, to rewrite and properly cite another paragraph of patchwork."

5. "Provide a set of facts, concepts, or arguments, including some that should be documented and others that count as common knowledge." 

  • "Ask the students, individually or in groups, to decide which is which and explain why."

6. "Give students a specific research question to address." 

  • "Provide a single, relevant article that includes at least two relevant references as a starting point."
  • "[A]sk them to generate a list of 10-15 other possible resources by working their way through a 'tree' of reference lists that branches off from the original two."

7. "Ask students to choose a field in which they consider themselves experts. (This doesn’t have to be academic.)"

  • "What lack of knowledge would prevent them from taking others seriously in this realm, and why?"
  • "Share with them some key texts or ideas that play a crucial role in establishing your own respect for other scholars."
    • "What omissions would prevent you from taking others seriously, and why?"

8. "Talk to students about your own academic genealogy—the scholars to whom you are indebted." 

  • "How do you fit into a larger picture of scholarly exchange?"
  • "How do you acknowledge your academic debts in your own writing?"

9. "Walk your students through a paragraph or two of a published text from your field." 

  • "Note the signaling moves that convey transitions between acknowledging research contributions of the past ... to original contributions the writers make in the present study." 
Printer Friendly, PDF & Email